Kneeling for Communion: Father Paul Weighs in on Vatican Decision

Home \ Kneeling for Communion: Father Paul Weighs in on Vatican Decision
communion

Kneeling for Communion: Father Paul Weighs in on Vatican Decision

As the Vatican backs a bishop’s restrictions on Communion rails and kneelers, Father Paul says respect for Church authority matters, even when Catholics disagree.

Catholics may disagree with decisions made by Church leaders, but Father Paul says they should still respect legitimate authority, even when they believe a decision is wrong.

“It’s always better to obey the legitimate authorities with regard to this than to kick up a fuss,” he said during a November 18 interview.

His comments came during a discussion about a Vatican decision supporting a North Carolina bishop’s controversial restrictions on the use of Communion rails and kneelers. The issue has attracted international attention following reports that the Vatican’s Dicastery for Divine Worship and the Discipline of the Sacraments upheld Bishop Michael Martin’s authority to prohibit the use of altar rails and kneelers during Communion in the Diocese of Charlotte.

Father Paul acknowledged that Catholics can sincerely believe such decisions are mistaken. But he said disagreement should not become an excuse for defiance.

“I would say cheerfully obey, not grudgingly or not mumbling under their breath,” he said.

A controversy over Communion rails

The decision, dated August 3 but made public November 18, rejected an appeal brought by a Catholic father who said he and his family had repeatedly been passed over for Communion while kneeling at an altar rail.

The controversy began in December 2025 when Bishop Martin directed parishes to discontinue distributing Communion at altar rails or using kneelers and similar supports for that purpose. The directive took effect January 16, 2026.

It drew objections from some clergy and parishioners who regarded kneeling as an important expression of reverence for the Eucharist. Thirty-one priests subsequently submitted questions to the Vatican concerning the bishop’s authority to impose the restrictions.

The right to kneel for Communion

The issue has also attracted attention beyond Charlotte. Earlier this year, Jonathan Roumie, who portrays Jesus in The Chosen, described on a podcast with Father Mike Schmitz, being told to stand when he knelt to receive Communion. His experience prompted a separate discussion about the rights of Catholics who choose to kneel.

At the heart of the dispute is an important distinction between a Catholic’s right to receive Communion while kneeling and the authority of a bishop to determine how Communion is distributed in his diocese.

The Church’s 2004 instruction Redemptionis Sacramentum states that Catholics cannot be refused Holy Communion solely because they wish to receive while kneeling or standing.

The Charlotte bishop’s directive does not eliminate that right. Instead, it restricts the use of altar rails, kneelers and similar structures during the distribution of Communion.

The Vatican upheld those restrictions, distinguishing between denying Communion because someone kneels and declining to distribute it at a location not authorized under diocesan arrangements.

Father Paul, who had not yet reviewed the Vatican decision when interviewed, said his understanding of Church teaching has been that kneeling is an acceptable expression of reverence. He also recalled temporary restrictions during the COVID-19, while emphasizing his understanding that Catholics ordinarily retain the right to receive Communion on the tongue.

Reverence and obedience

But Father Paul distinguished questions of Church discipline from matters of doctrine.

“When it comes to things like prudential decisions, the Church isn’t protected by the gift of infallibility,” he explained.

That means Catholics can reasonably question whether a particular disciplinary decision is wise, even while recognizing the authority of Church leaders to make it.

For Father Paul, the appropriate response is to respect that authority rather than allow disagreement over liturgical practices to become a source of division.

The Vatican’s ruling applies to the dispute in Charlotte. It does not establish a worldwide prohibition on kneeling for Communion or require Holy Trinity to change how the Eucharist is distributed.

Read More

Holy Trinity Catholic Church
Holy Trinity Catholic Church, located at 200 Boundary Rd. in Spruce Grove, Alberta, is led by Pastor Fr. Paul Moret and Associate Pastor Fr. Joselito Cantal.

Follow Us

Email Login
©2026 Holy Trinity Catholic Church | All Rights Reserved | Design by Panda Rose Consulting Studios
Hosted on Panda Cloud