Father Paul Moret Raises MAiD Concerns, Canadian Bishops Urge Parliament to Change Federal Bill

Home \ Father Paul Moret Raises MAiD Concerns, Canadian Bishops Urge Parliament to Change Federal Bill
Maid

Father Paul Moret Raises MAiD Concerns, Canadian Bishops Urge Parliament to Change Federal Bill

Holy Trinity pastor’s concerns about Catholic teaching, vulnerable patients and pastoral care come amid a national debate over assisted dying.

Canada’s Catholic bishops are calling on Parliament to reject proposed changes to medical assistance in dying (MAiD), adding urgency to concerns recently raised by Holy Trinity Parish’s Father Paul Moret about the moral and pastoral consequences of assisted death.

On November 12, the Canadian Conference of Catholic Bishops (CCCB) released a parliamentary brief urging MPs to separate two measures contained in Bill C-41, the federal government’s proposed Medical Assistance in Dying Safeguards Act.

The bishops support maintaining the current exclusion of people whose sole underlying medical condition is mental illness. However, they strongly oppose provisions that would allow certain patients to request euthanasia in advance, potentially years before losing the ability to consent.

The CCCB is also encouraging Catholics to contact their MPs ahead of an anticipated parliamentary vote.

The intervention comes as Alberta and Saskatchewan pursue additional provincial safeguards and Catholic priests across the country grapple with the implications of MAiD for their parishioners.

Father Paul raises concerns close to home

In a recent article by Terry O’Neill of Canadian Catholic News, Father Paul discussed his concerns about Catholics choosing MAiD, including the influence of personal conscience, pressure on vulnerable patients and the Church’s response when someone dies through assisted suicide or euthanasia.

Father Paul told the publication that he devoted a homily last March to Catholic teaching on the sanctity of human life following persistent rumours that two Holy Trinity parishioners had died through MAiD.

His intention was to ensure parishioners understood the Church’s opposition to euthanasia before making end-of-life decisions. Father Paul also questioned whether Catholics fully understand the relationship between personal conscience and established Church teaching.

He pointed specifically to the Canadian bishops’ 1968 Winnipeg Statement, issued following Pope Paul VI’s encyclical Humanae Vitae, suggesting its interpretation contributed to confusion about whether Catholics could disregard Church teaching on matters of conscience.

Are patients truly choosing freely?

Father Paul raised another concern that goes beyond religious doctrine: whether some people requesting MAiD are making genuinely free decisions.

“People are being pushed into it,” he told Canadian Catholic News.

He pointed to reports of patients experiencing pressure from family members, medical professionals or circumstances involving inadequate access to health care.

His concern is that such pressures may affect an individual’s personal responsibility for choosing medically assisted death.

Father Paul also drew a comparison with the Church’s understanding of suicide.

While Catholic teaching considers suicide a grave moral wrong, the Catechism recognizes that psychological disturbances, anguish and severe fear can diminish personal responsibility.

He questioned whether similar circumstances surrounding MAiD should influence how priests respond pastorally to the deceased and their families.

Father Paul expressed a desire for further guidance on these difficult situations.

His position does not change the Church’s opposition to euthanasia. Rather, it raises questions about how priests should accompany people who may have experienced extraordinary suffering, fear or pressure before death.

Read Father Paul’s full interview in Canadian Catholic News.

Canadian bishops call for changes to Bill C-41

In their November 12 statement, Canada’s Catholic bishops raised concerns about the federal government’s proposal to permit advance requests for euthanasia.

Under Bill C-41, an eligible adult diagnosed with a serious, incurable condition such as Alzheimer’s disease could make a request while still capable of providing informed consent.

If the individual subsequently lost decision-making capacity, MAiD could be provided if the applicable eligibility requirements and safeguards were met and the province had authorized advance requests.

The federal government says the proposed safeguards are intended to respect patients’ previously expressed wishes while protecting vulnerable people.

The bishops, however, question how medical professionals could confidently interpret an individual’s earlier wishes and present circumstances after that person could no longer understand or reconsider the decision.

Their parliamentary brief raises concerns about pressure, isolation, inadequate care and whether fears about future illness accurately reflect how patients eventually experience their condition.

The bishops also cite a 2025 recommendation from the United Nations Committee on the Rights of Persons with Disabilities opposing further expansion of MAiD through advance requests.

The CCCB wants Parliament to preserve the mental-illness exclusion through separate legislation before its scheduled expiry on March 17, 2027, while rejecting the proposed advance-request provisions.

Take action now

CCCB encourages Catholics and all Canadians to act immediately:

Participate in the CCCB’s letter-writing campaign.

Send a letter to your Member of Parliament without delay.

Alberta and Saskatchewan introduce additional safeguards

The bishops’ intervention comes amid legislative developments in Western Canada.

Alberta’s Bill 18, the Safeguards for Last Resort Termination of Life Act, received royal assent on May 14, 2026.

Once implemented, the legislation would restrict MAiD to individuals whose natural death is reasonably foreseeable, generally within 12 months, while prohibiting advance requests and strengthening protections for health-care professionals and certain facilities that object to participating.

The legislation is not yet in force, and Alberta Health Services says current MAiD procedures remain unchanged.

On November 9, Saskatchewan introduced Bill 73, proposing additional restrictions concerning minors, mental illness and patients lacking decision-making capacity, along with stronger conscience protections for medical professionals.

Several of these eligibility restrictions already exist in federal law, but the Saskatchewan proposal would also establish provincial safeguards.

More than 16,000 medically assisted deaths annually

According to Health Canada’s latest published national annual report, 16,499 Canadians received MAiD in 2024, representing approximately 5.1 per cent of all deaths.

Since legalization in 2016, 76,475 Canadians had received MAiD by the end of 2024.

The numbers illustrate the scale of the issue facing Canadian families, medical professionals and religious communities.

The Catholic Church continues to teach that euthanasia and assisted suicide are morally unacceptable, while emphasizing the obligation to provide compassionate care, appropriate pain relief, palliative care and spiritual accompaniment to those facing serious illness.

Bishops encourage Catholics to become informed

Alongside their parliamentary brief, the CCCB has released a fact sheet for parishes explaining Bill C-41, the Church’s concerns and the importance of supporting vulnerable people.

The bishops are encouraging Catholics to pray, discuss the issue respectfully and communicate their concerns to elected representatives.

For Holy Trinity parishioners, Father Paul’s comments place these national developments in a distinctly local context.

His concerns about personal conscience, pressure on vulnerable patients and the responsibilities of priests reflect the difficult questions facing the Church as Canada’s assisted-dying laws continue to evolve.

Further reading and resources

Canadian Catholic News: Priests seek guidance for pastoral response to Catholics seeking MAiD

Canadian Conference of Catholic Bishops: November 12 statement on Bill C-41

CCCB parish fact sheet: What Catholics Need to Know About Bill C-41

CCCB parliamentary brief on Bill C-41

Read More

Holy Trinity Catholic Church

Holy Trinity Catholic Church, located at 200 Boundary Rd. in Spruce Grove, Alberta, is led by Pastor Fr. Paul Moret and Associate Pastor Fr. Joselito Cantal.
Follow Us
Email Login

2026 Holy Trinity Catholic Church | All Rights Reserved | Design by Panda Rose Consulting Studios

Hosted on Panda Cloud